I remember reading an interview with Alan Moore where he stated that comic companies will try anything to bring in sales except have good writers and good artists. Flashpoint is a perfect example of this.
Flashpoint is DC's new event, which follows Brightest Day (which followed Blackest Night), and it has over 40 tie in issues. Trying to come up with the biggest marketing blitz in comics history apparently, DC has also decided to cancel all but two of their ongoing series (Green Lantern and Batman Inc are spared) and launch 52 (!) new ongoing series at issue #1. Re-launching a series from #1 with a new creative team isn't new, but nobody's ever done it for an entire line. The more important question to ask, however, is whether any of this will be worth reading. And if the stories will be good, why the re-numbering gimmick?
Not all of the new series have been announced, but a few sound promising. Grant Morrison writing Superman and Brian Azzaerrelo writing Wonder Woman for example. But again, these series would be good regardless of whether they were numbeed #1 or not.
Within three years, most of these new series will probably be cancelled and the old standbys (Action Comics, Detective Comics, etc) will have returned to their original numbering. How much continuity will be altered remains to be seen. Altering continuity is fine if it's in the interest of a good story, but if it's done at the behest of crass editorial policy (Younger! Hipper!) then it tends not to last and be badly received.
DC is trying awfully hard, but so far they haven't gotten me interested enough to buy a single issue of Flashpoint.
About Me
- Matt
- I'm a Social Anarchist and an avid reader of comics. Twitter handle is @armyofcrime.
Monday, June 6, 2011
Sunday, May 22, 2011
Mice Templar #4
Like many young adults, I consumed the Redwall series of books by Brian Jacques. The stories took place in a quasi medieval setting and featured mice, otters and other critters fighting wars against hordes of rats and other nefarious creatures.
Based on those fond memories, and on the cute title, I bought The Mice Templar #4 on a whim.
I love the art. It manages to be both cartoony and serious at the same time. Floppy eared mice fight to the death and discuss honor and religion. I was a bit lost on the plot, though. Jumping on at this point means I don't know much of what is going on. I'm going to try and follow this one though.
Batman Inc #6
I love Grant Morrison's run on Batman. It's one of the best stories by a single author on a company owned property in a long time. And as much as I want to love every single issue of Batman Inc, the sixth issue feels like a holding pattern.
We just finished getting introduced to Dr. Daedalus, meeting our main cast and learning a bit about the new enemy, Leviathan in the last five issues. This feels like a bridge issue. A pause while the action starts up again in number seven.
Not that it is bad. The art is great, reminiscent of Frank Quitely's art on Batman and Robin. Cassie is back and in action in Hong Kong. Red Robin joins the Outsiders. And Batman starts assembling his master plan. The reader just doesn't get to know what the plan is. And again, in the overall scheme of things, that's okay. All of Morrison's reveals so far have been great. But it feels like a bridge issue.
If this were any other comic, I would have thought the Average Joes were a cute addition. I would have liked seeing Batman trolling people on an Internet message board. And those are nice touches, but not enough to carry a whole issue.
Morrison has sometimes been accused of writing "for the trade." Having issues that only seem great when you read the whole story line together. Batman Inc #6 suffers from a bit of this. It's still enjoyable, but probably the weakest issue so far of Batman Inc. If you have been following Batman Inc steadily, then by all means pick it up. If you're looking for a jumping on point though, this isn't it.
Saturday, May 21, 2011
Free Comic Book Day #3
Amazing Spider Man- I actually got a couple laughs out of this. The art is fresh and although I have no idea where Spider-Man's current continuity is supposed to be at I enjoyed it. And it has Shang-Chi! Where has that guy been?
Kung-Fu Panda- Cute story, but I didn't really find it funny.
Richie Rich- Lame, no real adult appeal.
Baltimore- Mignola's art is great as always. Vampires feel a bit played out but seeing the story from a civilian's perspective, instead of the hunter, made it interesting. I would pick this up.
Green Lantern Secret Origins: A reprint of a story I've read before, that wasn't that good the first time. Yawn.
Flashpoint: A crossover starring Barry Allen. Something about a messed up timeline. Presumably the end will involve the restoration of the canon timeline. Double yawn.
The Tick: Who doesn't love the Tick? I should really pick up a trade or two of the Tick.
Captain America and Thor: An all ages Cap/Thor book. Shameless summer movie tie in? Odds point to yes.
Super-Dinosaur- This was pretty awesome.
Wednesday, May 18, 2011
Daredevil Reborn #4
Andy Diggle burnt Matt Murdock's life to the ground in Shadowland, and now he wraps up the four issue mini-series meant to transition the character into a new ongoing series. Daredevil Reborn #4 intentionally parallels Frank Miller's origin story in Man Without Fear. Matt dons a block costume and a wields a baton, using it to deflect an enemies bullet at the climax of the story. It is pretty undeniable that Miller's influence is more stark than probably any other writer's take on a character they didn't create themselves, and most Daredevil fiction always ends up aping Miller at some point.
Matt has inexplicably survived. He's a superhero so we knew he was going to survive. The interesting part of the scenario is trying to figure out how Matt will get out of this. The answer remains a mystery. Matt pulls himself out of a river, bleeding from his head, and wonders how he is still alive. So does the reader. Is this the "rebirth" we've been waiting for? Mysterious is one thing, but this feels lazy.
The standard arc for poor Murdock, post Born Again, is for the writer to torture him relentlessly, drive him to the brink of madness and let him crawl on his fingernails back to a functioning human being. Kevin Smith copied it studiously to ill results in Guardian Devil, Bendis inverted it a bit by having Murdock declare himself Kingpin in his moment of rage, and Brubaker broke his marriage up to pitch him into a massive depression. Andy Diggle, deciding that our intrepid hero hadn't suffered enough, turned him evil, had him get possessed by a demon and utterly ruined his life. At the end of Shadowland, Murdock packs his bags and leaves Hell's Kitchen in disgrace.
Throughout Reborn, the reader keeps waiting for something climatic and life affirming to happen. Matt confronts some backwoods arms dealers and only when he meets their super powered crime boss, Calavera does the story start to show potential. Striking an iconic pose as a white skinned dealer of evil, Calavera forces Matt to confront his inner demons, shoots him in the head and pushes him off of a cliff. That's where issue four opens up.
Matt has inexplicably survived. He's a superhero so we knew he was going to survive. The interesting part of the scenario is trying to figure out how Matt will get out of this. The answer remains a mystery. Matt pulls himself out of a river, bleeding from his head, and wonders how he is still alive. So does the reader. Is this the "rebirth" we've been waiting for? Mysterious is one thing, but this feels lazy.
Calavera has the power to bring out the darkness in people's souls. His use of this power on Matt lasts only a single panel. Murdock easily defeats his enemies and is back in Foggy's apartment by the end, promising that they will get their practice back, presumably bringing everything back to the status quo.
The whole series was disappointing, and the last issue lands with a wet thud.
Tuesday, May 17, 2011
Hal Boredom
Hal Jordan is played by Ryan Reynolds in the Green Lantern movie, and there is a new set of Green Lantern animated shorts coming out featuring him prominently. I, for one, find Hal Jordan to be an insufferably boring character. I read all of Geoff Johns' run on Green Lantern up through the end of Blackest Night before finally realizing that nothing interesting about the title had anything to do with Jordan.
Having never read the original John Broome stories, I couldn't say whether they are sublimely awesome or not. Maybe they are are work of art comporable to the 7 Seven Wonders of the World.
What I have read leaves me yawning enthusiastically. Jordan is a courageous hero who plays by his own rules and always gets the girl. He never seems to suffer any personal or emotional trauma. In other words, he is the same as every character in every action movie and pretty much every superhero that was never re-tooled for the Modern Age.
DC seems to struggle with what to do with Jordan, who has a paradoxical combination of ultimate power and a total lack of personality. Dennis O'Neil teamed him up with Green Arrow quite extensively, Jordan playing the straight man to Green Arrow's radicalism. O'Neil also created John Stewart, intended to be Jordan's back up in the Corps.
Deciding that a Green Lantern with recognizable character traits would appeal to a younger audience, DC had Hal try and blow up the universe, murdering the entirety of the Green Lantern Corps in the process. Kyle Rayner stepped in to the black and green spandex.
In another failed attempt to make Jordan interesting, he became the new Spectre, on a mission of redemption after trying to kill everyone and become God. This petered out a little after two years.
Geoff Johns decided that the world need Hal again, because straight white men with type A personalities were becoming a rare commodity in the comics industry. It turns out murdering all of his comrades and trying to erase existence only happened because he was possessed by an evil space entity. Apparently, someone forget to tell God, who let him become the Spectre to redeem himself. Or maybe God thought that was funny, Hal redeeming himself for things that weren't his fault.
As all characters and situations in continuity must revert to some arbitrarily chosen point in the status quo, so too did Green Lantern. Hal came back to life, was forgiven by everyone, become a fighter pilot again and started dating attractive women without missing a beat.
So it goes in the comics industry.
Monday, May 16, 2011
Free Comic Book Day #2: Witches and Wizards
I had no idea what to expect when I picked up Witches and Wizards. It appears to be an anime, written by some one named James Patterson, who apparently writes young adult. It's drawn and styled like mange, but created to read left to right. The plot seems to involve Nazis hunting down magic users, and our heroes are a family of witches targeted by the "New Order".
The purpose of the free preview is to get a person to buy more of that series. I don't plan on checking this one out, although I didn't have any real problem with it. It just seemed very conventional.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)